AC Milan lost the 2005 Champions League final to Liverpool on penalties after leading 3-0 at half-time. That match, played in Istanbul, has become shorthand for one of the great collapses in football. What often gets lost is how strong this Milan team was. Many of the players and opponents involved still rate it above the side that won the trophy two years later.
Istanbul still defines them
Paolo Maldini has said he played in eight European Cup finals and won five, yet people mostly want to talk about 2005. He told UEFA.com the defeat “left an indelible mark”.
In Maldini’s view, the game itself wasn’t one-sided in the way the result suggests. He told GOAL he was unable to rewatch it for a year. When he finally did, he realised Milan had controlled about 110 of the 120 minutes. All it reminded him of, he said, was how “cruel” football can be.
Maldini was the one who sent Milan ahead inside the opening minute, volleying a wide free-kick into the net. Crespo made it two just before the interval, chipping Jerzy Dudek after Kaka’s pass from inside his own half split Liverpool open. John Aldridge, a former Liverpool striker, said on local radio that Liverpool needed “a miracle”.
What came next
Rafa Benitez’s changes at half-time and Steven Gerrard’s refusal to give up are usually credited for the turnaround, and Liverpool were level by the hour. Carlo Ancelotti called the spell “six minutes of madness”. Gerrard’s looping header started it, and Vladimir Smicer’s long-range effort beat Dida two minutes later.
Stories that Milan’s players were celebrating in the dressing room have followed them ever since. Maldini rejects them. He told Italian podcaster Fedez that the players were shouting because tension was high, and that Ancelotti had to step in to calm things down. As captain, he said, he would never have allowed celebrations.
Milan did compose themselves and dominated the rest of the match. But Dudek’s point-blank stop from Andriy Shevchenko was, by the article’s account, arguably the best save in a Champions League final. Cafu has said that after it he “knew all was lost” before the shootout began.
Milan missed three of their five penalties, including Shevchenko’s, the same player who had scored the winning kick against Juventus in the 2003 final in Manchester. Liverpool won the shootout 3-2 and lifted a fifth European Cup.
Crespo has compared the dressing room afterwards to “a funeral”. Gennaro Gattuso, even while celebrating the 2007 win, said the pain of 2005 would stay with him “for a lifetime”. Andrea Pirlo has called it a lingering “pain in the arse”. Diego Maradona said at the time that he had never seen a comeback against a team so clearly superior.
A squad built to dominate
Milan went into 2004-05 as Serie A champions, their first title in five years. They had finished 11 points ahead of Roma. Ancelotti, long seen as a cup specialist, had shown he could win the league too.
The summer made them stronger. Jaap Stam arrived from Lazio to add to a defence that already looked unbeatable. Chelsea agreed to loan Hernan Crespo to Milan for a season. The article calls him still underrated.
The line-up read like a fantasy team:
- Goalkeeper: Dida
- Defence: Cafu, Stam, Alessandro Nesta, Maldini
- Midfield: Pirlo, Gattuso, Seedorf
- Attack: Kaka behind Crespo and Shevchenko
Gerrard later said Milan had one of the world’s best players in every position. Jamie Carragher, speaking on The Overlap, said the pre-final team photo showed “one of the best teams ever”.
The first crack: Deportivo in 2004
Ancelotti had already been through a European shock in the previous campaign. Milan beat Deportivo La Coruna 4-1 at San Siro in the first leg of their 2004 quarter-final. They then lost 4-0 at the Riazor to go out. Ancelotti called it “inexplicable” and said the club had to refocus on the league. They won it comfortably.
A season unravels in May 2005
By the end of April 2005, Milan were joint-top of Serie A with Juventus, ahead only on goal difference, and held a 2-0 lead over PSV from the first leg of the Champions League semi-final. They were in a strong position for a double.
The league was tough, as Milan’s results showed. They lost at Livorno and Siena and dropped points at home to Messina, Bologna and Brescia. Competing in Europe while chasing Fabio Capello’s Juventus was a heavy load.
The second leg against PSV on May 4 took a lot out of them. Milan lost 3-1 in Eindhoven and went through only on away goals, with Massimo Ambrosini scoring in the 91st minute. Ancelotti admitted the team had been scared at 2-0 down but praised how they kept going.
Four days later, David Trezeguet’s goal gave Juventus a 1-0 win at San Siro in a game that effectively decided the title. Draws with Lecce and Palermo followed. Juventus secured the scudetto five days before the final.
Gazzetta dello Sport’s Antonio Di Rosa wrote that Milan had earned their place in the final on merit and needed to recharge. By then, though, they had won nothing in May.
Liverpool, the underdogs
Despite the slump, Milan went into the final as clear favourites. Carragher has described the Liverpool side as “bang average”.
Liverpool had finished fifth in the Premier League, 37 points behind champions Chelsea. They needed a late Gerrard winner against Olympiacos just to get out of the group. Even so, they had knocked out Juventus and then Chelsea on the way to their sixth European Cup final.
Stam wasn’t taking them lightly. On the eve of the match he praised their defending, singled out Carragher and Gerrard, and said Milan being called favourites didn’t mean it would be easy.
The 2007 comparison
Milan beat Liverpool 2-1 in the 2007 final in Athens. It was a more complicated win, and not a vintage performance. Maldini, then 38, played through severe knee problems on heavy painkillers and remembers little of it. Ancelotti and Seedorf both conceded afterwards that Milan hadn’t played particularly well. Liverpool had twice as many shots.
Ancelotti has said 2007 was won through determination more than quality, and that the team was technically inferior to the 2005 version. Shevchenko, Stam and Crespo had all left by then. Cafu, 36, had lost his place to Massimo Oddo.
Why it still matters
Milan won the 2007 title and avenged Istanbul. But Ancelotti’s strongest team in his eight years at San Siro finished 2004-05 without a single major trophy. That’s why the 2005 side is still discussed as a team that should have gone down as one of the greatest of all time.
Also Read : Dortmund and Guinea in talks over injured striker Serhou Guirassy




2 thoughts on ““One of the best teams ever”: How Ancelotti’s star-studded AC Milan ended 2005 with nothing”