Nicky Butt says Lisandro Martínez would have been in serious trouble in the Manchester United dressing rooms of the past.
Speaking on Piers Morgan Uncensored, the six-time Premier League winner criticised the defender’s form, his interview after the Atlético Madrid defeat and his Falklands banner at the World Cup. “Back in my day, he would have completely had his head ripped off,” Butt said.
Atlético interview under fire
Martínez spoke out after United’s 2-0 Champions League defeat by Atlético Madrid. He criticised the club’s transfer strategy and said he “expected more” from technical director Jason Wilcox.
Butt thinks the timing was poor, because Martínez is not playing well himself. He said the defender had the audacity to “slag off the powers-that-be” over signings. If United did buy new players, Butt added, Martínez would be among the first to be replaced.
Status makes no difference to him. “Even if he was European player of the year, you still don’t speak that way about your team-mates,” he said.
Butt believes players in his era would have confronted Martínez, asking who he thought he was to talk about them like that with performances like his.
Chelsea red card
Martínez was sent off on Saturday for conceding a penalty in United’s 2-0 loss to Chelsea. Butt picked out an elbow the defender threw in that game, which he put down to Martínez being “not strong enough to defend properly”.
He also said today’s players take criticism badly, which makes it hard to speak to them honestly.
The Falklands banner
Butt then turned to the World Cup. After Argentina beat England 2-1 in the semi-final, Martínez was among the players who held up a banner reading “Las Malvinas son Argentinas”, meaning “The Falklands are Argentine”.
Fifa fined Argentina £235,000 for what was described as a political demonstration. Martínez was not punished individually.
Butt was not impressed. “He lives in our country and he’s dancing around with an Argentina flag at the World Cup,” he said.
He also mocked players on £200,000 a week who drive a Rolls Royce through their village and expect praise. They cannot have people patting them on the back, he said, when they play badly and criticise others.
Fans have turned
Butt said he does not know why, but Martínez has gone from a player the fans love to one they want out of the club. In his view, the defender has done the damage himself.
Martínez now faces criticism over his form, the red card at Chelsea and his comments about United’s bosses.




